Wednesday, September 27, 2023

'The Various Light' - Monica Redlich

Monica Redlich (1909-1963) had some success with a light-hearted book, The Young Girl’s Guide to Good Behaviour (1935), which has been reprinted several times. She was married to Sigurd Christensen, a Danish diplomat, and wrote several books about that country, and another explaining English ways and customs to overseas readers, originally those in Denmark but later for wider consumption. 

This was Everyday England (1957, rev ed 1964). It is observant, affectionate but not uncritical.  In fact, it is both enjoyable and useful today as a portrait of England then to England now, since the past is also, as L.P. Hartley so memorably observed, a foreign country.

She worked for a while as secretary to L.A.G. Strong, and co-edited with him Life in English Literature, an Introduction for Beginners (1932). He dedicated his novel The Seven Arms (1935) to her. As well as her non-fiction, she was also the author of a few novels with family and domestic themes. In 1970 her husband edited a fragment of autobiography by her, The Unfolding Years, together with a preface by him and a bibliography of her work.

This begins; ‘Monica Mary Redlich was born on 3 July 1909 at Boston, Lincolnshire, where her father, the Rev. Edwin Basil Redlich, was then a curate. Her mother, Maud Le Bas Le Maistre, came of a Jersey family.’ When she was fifteen he became Rector of Little Bowden, Market Harborough. She took a degree in English Literature at the University of London in 1931.

My interest in her work began when I found her now forgotten fantasy, The Various Light (1948), which I took from the shelves because I thought the title sounded promising. The epigraph shows that it is a quotation from Andrew Marvell’s ‘Thoughts in a Garden’, and refers to the soul which ‘prepared for longer flight,/Waves in its plumes the various light.’

It starts conventionally enough with a dinner party of friends and relations all with links to a village where they grew up – they are the children of the squire, the parson and the doctor, and are with their spouses or partners. The characters are carefully drawn, and we soon build a sense of their qualities and their all-too-human failings. One strand of the novel depicts their changing marital and extra-marital relationships as some of them are drawn to different partners than their current ones.

But there is another, much more unusual, strand in which most of them meet when they dream in a shared visionary world, where their roles and relationships are different. Here they move in a celestial landscape and are part of a sort of mystical college, where mentors help them to understand where they are going wrong and what they ought to do. This guidance does not necessarily bear any relation to earthly morality.

There are some qualities that resonate in both worlds, for example, music, gardens, landscape and the sea, and these provide the characters in their diurnal world with elusive echoes of their dream experiences, which they do not otherwise recall in detail. Some chapter titles indicate these: ‘The Other Music’; ‘Many-Coloured Glass’; ‘Altered Landscape’; ‘The Silver Tree’; ‘Lost City’. In this respect, the novel has some affinities with David Lindsay’s use of music and landscape to symbolise spiritual states. The combination of the novel of social relationships and of the otherworldly is similar to his approach in, for example, Sphinx (1923) and The Violet Apple (1976).

The author skilfully delays the point at which her characters find out in their everyday lives that they all dreamed, on one particular night, of very similar scenes and symbols.  They then explore the shared imagery and speculate upon what it means. This takes place after a supper party, in a garden at twilight, as they each reveal what they know in turn, some enthusiastic, others diffident, some sceptical, others taken by the wonder of it. Here she achieves a delicate, beguiling quality.

The philosophy of the dream institution Monica Redlich depicts is not doctrinaire, nor is it overtly drawn from the conventional faiths as such. Some of the assumptions seem to chime with theosophical and New Age thinking, particularly the idea of astral travel, of having a spiritual form beyond the physical one, and of karma. These concepts are also found in Ronald Fraser’s mystical novels. But her work does not have the more exotic aspects of other New Age fiction, such as reincarnation or scenes from Atlantis.

I think it is quite tricky to describe a sort of celestial self-improvement centre with wise mentors and pleasant landscapes without the reader feeling a bit restless about so much sweetness and light. One could imagine Robert Aickman, with a wicked glee, satirising an earthly counterpart of just this sort of thing: indeed, I think he almost did in one or two of his stories. But, like him, and as her Everyday England book might suggest, Monica Redlich is highly observant of English middle-class social niceties and conventions, and this gives her everyday scenes composure. Depicting the supernal realm is perhaps better done through myth and symbol rather than through an institution, however benevolent.

The Various Light is a thoughtful, distinctive novel. There are not the dramatic incursions often a feature of fantastic and supernatural literature, so some readers may find the book a bit subdued.  It is measured in its pace and careful in the development of its theme. Unusually, it depicts the otherworldly through human relationships, and it does so subtly. Its flawed characters are well-realised and some have an original savour. The overlapping of the unearthly into this world is handled with finesse. I think it is a book that repays our attention. Unfortunately, there are not that many copies about.

(Mark Valentine)

Wednesday, September 20, 2023

The Troubling of the City

‘Suppose that a number of fiends from Hell were sent to make war on a modern English cathedral city . . .’

Not the plot of a hitherto unknown Charles Williams or C S Lewis novel, but the enticing opening sentence of the blurb for an early Sixties fantastical thriller, The Troubling of the City (1962), also described by the publisher as ‘a new engagement of ‘The War in Heaven’’. The book’s epigraph is from Revelation XII, verses 7-9 and 12, the origin of that phrase, which was also used by Williams as the title of his first published novel.

The author, Roger Lloyd (1901-1966), was a Canon in the Cathedral close at Winchester, where he was appointed Vice-Dean, and the city provides the setting for his novel. He explains in a foreword that it was ‘first written to be read aloud on seven successive evenings to a conference of the Servants of Christ the King’ at the city, but has been much revised and expanded for book publication. The plot also takes place in part at a retreat and conference, on the theme of reconciliation.  The SCK organisation had been founded by Lloyd in 1943.

He was a prolific writer of books on theology and related social issues, and also incidentally (like many clergymen) a railway enthusiast, issuing three books on that subject. He had some success with two epistolary historical fictions, The Letters of Luke the Physician (1957) and Letters from the Early Church (1960). After these he also wrote a literary study, The Borderland: An Exploration of Theology in English Literature (1960), with examples that included Charles Williams. Like Williams (and Eliot, and Mary Butts, and Dorothy L. Sayers), Lloyd was evidently of the High Church persuasion.

Lloyd says in the Preface to this latter book that among citizens of the ‘Borderland’ he discusses, ‘one of its most recent, and certainly most honoured, was Charles Williams of blessed memory.’ He was, he tells us later, ‘the spiritual adviser of so many who had the luck to have his friendship, and, in all but name, the confessor of some of them’. The book does not offer a close critical study of Williams, but he is clearly a major influence on the author’s ideas.

His fictional approach, however, is rather different to Williams. A strength in Williams’ novels is his cast of all-too-human characters, with failings and foibles, whom we get to know first before the full force of the supernatural is evident. This is the approach also adopted by M R James in his ghost stories: to start with the fairly familiar before you introduce the unearthly.

By contrast, the first few chapters of The Troubling of the City depict the machinations of a princely demon sent to Winchester to undermine the city, and his conference with a few minor resident demons, whose infernal work has not been judged effective enough. The conceit of the conspiring, and not always competent, demons will call to mind the flavour of C S Lewis’ The Screwtape Letters (1942).  Lloyd also introduces celestial figures who have been sent to aid the city, including a converted buccaneer, St Swithin and King Alfred.

The ancient city of Winchester is not described in a lyrical and vivid way, as for example Machen does with Caerleon. There are episodes in the cathedral and other notable places, and even a few contemporary touches, such as a scene in a Robinson Crusoe themed beatnik coffee bar, but there is not a strong sense of place. I think this is because the novel is driven more by pace and polemic than by atmosphere or mood. There are some effective scenes outside the city, for example at a gathering of demons at the Devil’s Punchbowl, and in the series of malevolent attacks on a monk travelling through London, but these are linked to action rather than ambience.

Charles Williams’ novels gain by deploying talismans with a rich heritage of symbolism, such as the Grail, the Tarot, the Stone of Solomon and the Platonic Images. These impart an aura of magic and mystery which contrasts with the everyday lives of the characters and opens entrances to other dimensions. There are glimpses of one or two localised ancient objects in Roger Lloyd’s book, but they are not to the fore.

On the other hand, his book does have the shrewd idea that it is easier to undermine a city and a community by building up manifold minor irritations – locked gates, blocked roads, noise, sleeplessness, all leading to bad temper – rather than by more dramatic supernatural incursions. It is no doubt a sound pastoral insight: but it does not make for sweeping drama (though there is some of that too).

I think it would have to be conceded, therefore, that the Canon’s book does not have the sophistication or nuance of Williams or Lewis, either in the metaphysics or in the literary qualities, and it is also more earnest and missionary in tone. Nor does it quite avoid the problem Milton encountered in Paradise Lost – that his Satan was rather too glamorous and compelling, as is the princely Archdemon here. Even so, the novel has its own brisk sincerity, a certain brio and a clear resolve, and is an interesting example of a supernatural thriller in the service of theology, seeking to follow in the tradition of the two Inklings.

(Mark Valentine)

Sunday, September 17, 2023

E.R. Eddison at His Day Job

E.R. Eddison's day job was as a civil servant, but few sources say anything about what specifically he did. His obituary in The Times, notes that he entered the Board of Trade in 1906: "He was private secretary to successive Presidents of the Board from 1915 to 1919, and in 1923 was the secretary to the Imperial Economic Conference. The distinction of his service was recognized by the C.M.G. in 1924 and the C.B. in 1929. When he retired in 1938 to devote his whole time to literature, he had for eight years been Deputy Comptroller-General in the Department of Overseas Trade" (24 August 1945). 

Here is one account of his involvement on one Board of Trade issue. This report comes from The Chemical Age, 10 September 1921, p. 317. 



Wednesday, September 13, 2023

Dare Segun Falowo Appeal

Tartarus Press have issued the following appeal: ‘Dare Segun Falowo, author of Caged Ocean Dub, finds himself in a difficult situation in his home country of Nigeria. This wonderfully talented author was recently harrassed and attacked, and a GoFundMe page has been created to help him find a new and safe home. If you are able to make a donation, it will be greatly appreciated.’